fengshui.engine audit

Classical Texts Register 典籍總表 28 titles

Twenty-eight fengshui (kanyu 堪輿) texts, collated for attribution, era, content and school affiliation — including the ones tradition gets wrong about its own authors.

Opened 2026-10-10 · first-hand basis: 《欽定四庫全書總目》 Siku Quanshu Zongmu (Imperial Catalogue), vols. 109–111 · every claim below comes from our collation register; nothing is added from memory.

Editorial principle: every entry carries two separate fields — attributed_author (the author tradition assigns) and attribution_status (what the collation actually supports: original work 原著, pseudo-epigraphic 偽托, doubtful 存疑, or falsely ascribed 托名). We never write "Guo Pu wrote the Zangshu": the Siku cataloguers examined that claim in 卷109 and concluded the received 《葬書》 is a Song-era composition attributed to him. Where a verdict exists in the catalogue, we quote it; where none is recorded in our register, we say so rather than invent one.

How to read the badges

Badgeattribution_statusMeaning
original 原著original / securely ascribedAuthorship (or imperial compilation) is attested without a competing verdict in our register.
doubtful 存疑doubtfulAttribution cannot be settled — e.g. the catalogue says a text "only surfaces in the Song" 「至宋始出」, or the attributed author's dates are unverified.
falsely ascribed 偽托/托名pseudo-epigraphic / falsely ascribedThe catalogue (or the collation) explicitly judges the attribution spurious — e.g. 「是書蓋依托也」.

Doubt and spuriousness are different verdicts and are never merged. doubtful means "unresolved"; falsely ascribed means "resolved, against the attribution".

The core twenty 核心二十種

#TitleUsual English nameEraSchoolAttribution
1葬書(葬經) Zangshu → entryBook of Burialattr. Jin; received text cut by Song–Yuan editorsForm 形巒 — founding text of both later lineagesfalsely ascribed — Song-era (per Siku)
2青囊經 Qingnang Jing → entryGreen Satchel Classicattr. ancient (黃石公); received text with Qing commentaryThree-Cycle Xuankong 三元玄空 — theoretical frameworkdoubtful
3青囊奧語 Qingnang Aoyu → entryEsoteric Sayings of the Green Satchelattr. Tang; "surfaces only in the Song" (Siku)Three-Cycle liqi 理氣 — fountainheaddoubtful
4天玉經 Tianyu Jing → entryHeavenly Jade Classicattr. Tang; "surfaces only in the Song" (Siku)Three-Cycle Xuankong 三元玄空doubtful
5都天寶照經 Dutian Baozhao JingTreasured Illumination Classicattr. Tang 楊筠松; transmitted with Qing supplementThree-Cycle Xuankong (plain-terrain 平洋)doubtful — old attribution unverified
6催官篇 Cui Guan Pian → entryPrompting OfficialdomSong — Lai Wenjun 賴文俊Three Harmony / asterism 三合/天星 (pure-yin pure-yang)original — catalogued, no dissent
7雪心賦 Xuexin FuRhapsody on the Snowy HeartTang — Bu Yingtian 卜應天; Ming annotationForm 形巒original
8地理五訣 Dili WujueFive Formulae of GeographyQing — Zhao Tingdong 趙廷棟; 1880 ed.Three Harmony 三合 (Four Major Water Gates)original
9陽宅三要 Yangzhai San Yao → entryThree Essentials of the Yang DwellingQing — Zhao Jiufeng 趙九峰Eight Mansions 八宅original
10陽宅十書 Yangzhai ShishuTen Books on Yang DwellingsMing — Wang Junrong 王君榮; 1882 ed.Eight Mansions + form miscellanyoriginal
11八宅明鏡 Bazhai Mingjing → entryBright Mirror of the Eight MansionsQing — Ruoguan Daoren 箬冠道人; commercial eds. mis-attribute to YangEight Mansions 八宅falsely ascribed — Yang attribution unverified
12沈氏玄空學 Shen Shi Xuankong Xue → entryShen's Xuankong Studieslate Qing — Shen Shaoxun 沈紹勳 (1849–1906), posthumously compiledThree-Cycle Xuankong 三元玄空 (flying stars)original — compiled by son and students
13地理辨正 Dili Bianzheng → entryRectification of GeographyQing — Jiang Pingjie 蔣平階 (supplement), Jiang Yao 姜垚 (collation)Three-Cycle Xuankong 三元玄空original
14宅經(黃帝宅經) Zhai Jing → entryClassic of the Dwellingattributed to the Yellow EmperorEight Mansions / dwelling divination — fountainheadfalsely ascribed (per Siku)
15魯班經(魯班經匠家鏡) Luban JingLu Ban's Classic: The Craftsman's MirrorMing — compiled by Wu Rong 午榮; Wanli-era ed.Form / building lore 形法/營造original
16欽定協紀辨方書 Xieji Bianfang Shu → entryImperially Commissioned Manual for Harmonising Seasons and Discriminating DirectionsQing 1741, imperial commission; 36 juanDate selection 擇日 — official compendiumoriginal — imperial compilation
17選擇宗鏡 Xuanze ZongjingPrincipal Mirror of Date SelectionMing compilation — now attributed to Wu Tianhong 吳天洪Date selection + mingzao 造命falsely ascribed — "Yang Yunsong" is a vendor attribution
18象吉通書 Xiangji TongshuXiangji Complete AlmanacQing, Kangxi era — Wei Jian 魏鑑 (biography unrecorded)Date selection (almanac), with Three-Cycle materialoriginal — compiler named; first-edition year unverified
19鰲頭通書 Aotou TongshuAotou Complete AlmanacMing — compiled by Xiong Zongli 熊宗立; Qing revisionDate selection (almanac)doubtful — compiler's dates (1409–1482) unverified
20永寧通書 Yongning TongshuYongning Complete AlmanacQing — Wang Weide 王維德 (1669–1749); earliest recorded ed. 1800Date selection + Eight Mansions (dwellings)original

The further eight 另八種

#TitleUsual English nameEraSchoolAttribution
21入地眼全書 Rudayan QuanshuComplete Book of the Earth-Entering Eyeattr. Song — monk Jingdao 釋靜道 (= 辜托長老); Song dating rests only on Qing prefaces; earliest ed. 1821Form 巒頭 + Three Harmony nine-star; Eight Mansions for dwellingsdoubtful
22地理人子須知 Renzi XuzhiWhat a Son Must Know: GeographyMing — Xu Weizhi 徐維志 & Xu Weishi 徐維事; expanded 1583Form 形巒 / Jiangxi lineoriginal
23堪輿漫興 Kanyu ManxingCasual Verses on Kanyuattr. Ming — Liu Ji 劉基Form 形巒 (verse form, no liqi)doubtful — nowadays mostly judged spurious
24發微論 Fawei LunTreatise on Elucidating the Subtleattr. Song — Cai Yuanding 蔡元定 (Siku: possibly his father Cai Fa)Form theory 形巒理論doubtful — attribution kept per Siku practice
25玉尺經(平砂玉尺經) Yuchi Jing → entryJade Ruler Classicattr. Yuan — Liu Bingzhong 劉秉忠, with Ming "Liu Ji" notes; Siku: Ming forgeryThree Harmony 三合 — its pillar textfalsely ascribed — Ming (per Siku)
26天機素書 Tianji Su ShuPlain Book of the Celestial Mechanismattr. Tang — Qiu Yanhan 邱延翰; Siku: Ming forgeryForm (dragon-seeking) with asterism materialfalsely ascribed — Ming (per Siku)
27山洋指迷 Shanyang ZhimiPointing the Way through Mountains and PlainsMing — Zhou Jingyi 周景一; first complete ed. 1787Form 形巒 (three juan mountains, one juan plains)original
28地理啖蔗錄 Dianzhe LuTasting the Sugarcane: Records of GeographyQing — Yuan Shouding 袁守定; written Qianlong eraForm 形巒original — first-edition year unverified

School affiliation matrix 流派歸屬

Compiled from the collation register's cross-classification. ◎ main body · ○ partial · △ minor · × absent.

TitleThree Harmony 三合Three-Cycle 三元Eight Mansions 八宅Form 形巒Date selection 擇日/通書
葬書、雪心賦、人子須知、堪輿漫興、發微論、天機素書、山洋指迷、啖蔗錄×××◎×
催官篇◎××○×
青囊經、青囊奧語、天玉經、都天寶照經、地理辨正、沈氏玄空學×◎×○×
地理五訣、玉尺經◎××○×
宅經、陽宅三要、陽宅十書、八宅明鏡××◎○×
入地眼全書○△○ (dwellings)◎×
魯班經××○◎○
協紀辨方書、選擇宗鏡、象吉通書、鰲頭通書、永寧通書×△○ (永寧)×◎

Detailed entries

Twelve titles have full entry pages with the dual attribution fields, Siku verdicts, content summaries and full-text links:

葬書 Book of Burial · 青囊經 · 青囊奧語 · 天玉經 · 催官篇 · 宅經 · 地理辨正 · 沈氏玄空學 · 陽宅三要 · 八宅明鏡 · 欽定協紀辨方書 · 玉尺經

Where the texts can be read

Open repositories verified reachable at collation time (HTTP 200): ctext.org (Chinese Text Project), zh.wikisource.org (Wikisource), shidianguji.com (Shidian Guji), kanripo.org, daizhige.org, archive.org. Per-title links are on the individual entry pages. Repositories that failed verification (unreachable, 404 or uncorrected OCR) are not cited.

No popularity claims: this register ranks nothing by search interest or fame. Inclusion means "collated and source-anchored", nothing else. Where our engine's implementation disputes touch a text (Xuankong replacement-star 替卦; Eight Mansions star derivations), the entry links to the School Dispute Register.